Best Practices from Leading Companies on Building Productive Mentoring Programs

New employees have mentors, whether they are appointed by management or they step into the role on their own. Some people like to offer advice and model behavior. Others need and seek it. But, management cannot leave that to chance. Check the Goodreads Books, by Louis Carter How do business leaders create and structure a […]

Is your company a Most Loved Workplace®?

Join 1,000+ certified organizations worldwide

New employees have mentors, whether they are appointed by management or they step into the role on their own. Some people like to offer advice and model behavior. Others need and seek it. But, management cannot leave that to chance.

Check the Goodreads Books, by Louis Carter

How do business leaders create and structure a mentor program with immediate and lasting effect? They dismiss the babysitting and mothering modes, in favor of well-structured and well-measured programs aimed at employee retention, leadership development, and process improvement. While the investment in dollars and time works better for the larger company, the smaller business can pursue the same goals and scale their program structure to fit their business environment.

1. Work on connectivity – best practices at McGraw-Hill.

Convinced of the value in employee engagement, McGraw-Hill built its mentoring program on cultivating connectivity. They sought connectivity among co-workers, across work functions, and between the employee and the work. McGraw-Hill is, after all, in the education and training business, which might condition their strategic approach to facilitating engagement. They mined the analytics they had on current employees, leading them to interview the most promising and willing candidates for the role of mentor. Those interviews created profiles of interest, motivation, and experience. Based on that, they were able to recruit, hire, place, and groom employees directly into mentee roles matched to those select mentors. This functional match connects people, skills, goals, and futures in a positive way.

2. Commit to the long-term – best practices at Caterpillar.

At Caterpillar, mentorship is neither a sometime nor a one-time thing. Some places end mentorship at the end of the employee’s probationary period, and some introduce mentor and mentee and, then, leave it to them to stay in touch. Caterpillar, however, structures a two to three-year plan promoted as its Professional Development Program. Caterpillar leadership has committed to assimilate recent college student hires into the brand and blood of the corporation. Shortly into onboarding, each hire has some sense of direction and growth. During their mentoring curriculum, they rotate through functions and operations to develop technical abilities, relationships with senior management, and leadership skills. The program’s reputation precedes it and helps recruit and retain the most promising mentees.

3. Measure the experience – best practices at Sodexo.

In its commitment to diversity, Sodexo’s Spirit of Mentoring creates cross-divisional, cross-functional, and cross-cultural pairings. In each pairing, the mentee rules. Sodexo pairs mentor and mentee in partnerships in which the mentee speaks to his/her goals and preferred methodologies. The mentor listens to what the mentee wants, and they “negotiate” how they will achieve that. Still, it integrates functioning participatory roles for the program manager, implementation team, senior leadership, and human resources. The process, then, follows a formal calendar wherein metrics are reviewed regularly. The calendar requires monthly 90-minute meetings between mentor and mentee.

Read the Today’s Performance Management project

At two months, the IMPACT Team runs a check on progress. At the 4-month, 8-month, and 12-month marks, a webinar is followed by an e-survey on progress. Experience shows 95 percent of both mentors and mentees report a positive experience. Other survey results report on perceived job satisfaction, organizational commitment, and increased diversity awareness. No result has hit 100 percent, but the useful data identifies positive and negative concerns. Sodexo is able to analyze the ROI as the result of increased retention, improved leadership potential, and positioning as an employer of choice. Whether you are McGraw Hill, Caterpillar or a small to mid-sized shop, you can begin the process of mentoring through a structured matching and goal-orientation program. As long as your program has disciplined follow-up and you are clear about your desired outcomes of your program for the business, you will have a success case. Mentoring can have enormously valuable effects for your business when you connect it to your business strategy. Be sure to respect the tradition. Once you do, your employees will quickly follow suit.

Ready to Build a Loved Workplace?

Take the first step — check your organization’s CertCheck score or apply for certification today.

Frequently Asked Questions

The biggest large employer culture challenges during a spinout or major transformation include: maintaining consistent culture signals across geographically dispersed teams, preventing a vacuum of identity when the legacy brand disappears, and preserving the informal trust networks that made the old organization function. Companies like Kyndryl, which spun out of IBM with 73,000 employees across 5 continents, show that culture infrastructure—systematic onboarding, explicit values, leadership accessibility—must be deliberately built, not assumed to transfer.

Maintaining consistent culture across global offices requires moving from aspirational values to operational infrastructure. The evidence from Kyndryl's Most Loved Workplace certification shows that when employees in Asia Pacific, Europe, North America, South America, and the UK independently describe their culture using the same language—'flexible work,' 'you are heard,' 'career and learning outcomes'—it is not coincidence. It is the result of systematic design: shared onboarding, visible leadership behavior, and consistent feedback loops that translate values into daily experience regardless of location or time zone.

A Most Loved Workplace® certification proves that a company's culture claims are independently verified through employee assessment—not self-reported surveys or marketing copy. The certification uses machine learning to analyze sentiment, emotion, and recurring themes across thousands of employee responses. When a large employer like Kyndryl earns this certification despite a major transformation, it demonstrates that their culture infrastructure survived and scaled through disruption, which is the hardest test any organizational culture can face.

About Louis Carter

Louis Carter is the Founder and CEO of Best Practice Institute (BPI) and Most Loved Workplaces®, a global research and certification organization helping companies build workplaces employees love. He is the creator of the Love of Workplace Index™, a research-based framework used to measure emotional connection between employees and their organizations and predict performance, retention, and culture outcomes. Carter is the author of more than a dozen books on leadership, talent development, and management best practices and has advised Fortune 500 companies, government agencies, and global organizations on leadership and culture transformation. He also hosted the Leader Show, a leadership interview series featured on Newsweek for five years, interviewing executives and leadership experts about leadership and the future of work. His work on workplace culture and leadership has been featured in major publications including Newsweek, The Wall Street Journal, and The Economist. Learn more in “How Louis Carter’s Most Loved Workplace Measures What Really Matters” (New York Business Now) and “Beyond Employer Branding: How Louis Carter Built the Global Standard for Workplace Culture” (NY Tech Media)

Get Certified?

Join 1,000+ Most Loved Workplaces®

In this Article

What's Next ?

Start your certification journey

Book a Call

Discuss your culture challenges with the Louis Carter team

Continue Reading