Best Practices in Performance Management Transitions

Performance management software is an on-demand SaaS system that lets an organization process and standardize appraisals of employees and managers. Ideally, it is an opportunity for managers to clarify employee work expectations, align set personal goals with corporate objectives, share constructive feedback, and identify and develop talent. Succession planning and talent management depend on performance […]

performance management transitions

Is your company a Most Loved Workplace®?

Join 1,000+ certified organizations worldwide

Performance management software is an on-demand SaaS system that lets an organization process and standardize appraisals of employees and managers. Ideally, it is an opportunity for managers to clarify employee work expectations, align set personal goals with corporate objectives, share constructive feedback, and identify and develop talent.

Succession planning and talent management depend on performance management. So, it contributes to continuous improvement, builds relationships, justifies compensation, and rewards employees. Finding affordable software solutions suitable to industry type and size presents some challenges in a market full of available products.

Reviewsnap – Best Practices at Penske Racing

A self-service, fully-automated performance management system, Reviewsnap has 1,200 customers worldwide. Intuitive, dependable, it provides SaaS solutions to improve your organization’s performance management.

A one stop source for performance appraisals, 360° feedbacks, and compensation tracking, Reviewsnap engages employees and management. It improves efficiency with communication and coaching, and seeks to align individual performance with team and organizational goals.

Penske Racing tried several products before opting for Reviewsnap. They found them difficult to use, and while they continued their legacy paperwork process creating more work and frustration all around.

Collaboration between teams from Penske and Reviewsnap decided to continue use of Penske’s existing review form. And, Reviewsnap would easily integrate with ADP, Penske’s employee portal and payroll system. Both issues enabled a seamless installation.

In addition, the new system generates reminders to managers, thus, saving time. More important, the software allows authorized users to see how managers are meeting their obligations.  As a result, employees are happy performance reviews are done on time and HR is happy to save hours on processing.

Skillrater – Best Practices at Becton Dickinson

The difference between Skillrater and other performance tools is that it is concise and provides specific feedback, less rating and it is based on positive dialogue and feed-forward – all of which reduce rater fatigue and increases respect for the employee.  This has enabled BD Early Career Experience employees to be more likely to give, receive, and request feedback on a more frequent basis.  This is the direction in which BD was moving as it offers an alternative to other, more traditional, 360-degree processes which are long and create a great deal of rater fatigue.

Using Skillrater has been an effective way for BD- ECE associates to reach out quickly to stakeholders and get feedback.  In addition, it provides me and other leaders with access to big data around the star performers and leaders whom we may need to position for specific project assignments in the future.

Appraisd – Best Practices at Charles Trywhitt

A global, multi-channel, clothing retailer, Charles Trywhitt needed to upgrade and update its systems for 400 employees. They were tired of what had become a useless system at odds with what they considered their entrepreneurial culture.

Appraisd gave them what they were looking for in two weeks. Customizable features let them build an approach that employees readily adopted. For example, Appraisd bunches reminders into one email to prompt manager response. Assessment results rate performers to help executive leadership strategize plans and actions.

The software initiates 360° feedback in a process customized with Charles Trywhitt. And, this effectively coaches and monitors line managers into better performance management. It even increases the frequency of reviews by posting objectives for a 15-minute monthly sit-down session between manager and employee.

SilkRoad – Best Practices at SIRVA®

The global reach of SIRVA® lets it relocate thousands of people annually. Holding mortgage companies through moving vans, SIRVA® has a surprisingly outdated performance management system. Because they move people, families, and belongings, they have to be flexible, agile, and innovative.

Team driven by a Six Sigma orientation, SIRVA® HR found itself fighting to satisfy and engage thousands of employees over scores of global locations. The could not keep up with scattered and frequently changing membership. Scheduling, meetings, reviews, and goal setting took too long, and they proved meaningless by the time they were finally completed. So frustrated, HR throughout its software and returned to manual processes until they could find an adequate solution.

SilkRoad gave their search team a cloud-based, scalable, and intuitive solution at a more than competitive price. SilkRoad would integrate data from all brands and locations and put it in one accessible place.

SIRVA® made a bit of a cultural move touting the transition as “Moving through SIRVA®,” and management could finally see all employees in one place. They could observe each employee’s talents and goals and assess how their performance was or was not taking them there. The process freed hours of administrative work on the part of individual managers and HR at headquarters. Employees have found added value in the user-friendly interface and in HR’s new agility and responsiveness.

Ready to Build a Loved Workplace?

Take the first step — check your organization’s CertCheck score or apply for certification today.

Frequently Asked Questions

The biggest large employer culture challenges during a spinout or major transformation include: maintaining consistent culture signals across geographically dispersed teams, preventing a vacuum of identity when the legacy brand disappears, and preserving the informal trust networks that made the old organization function. Companies like Kyndryl, which spun out of IBM with 73,000 employees across 5 continents, show that culture infrastructure—systematic onboarding, explicit values, leadership accessibility—must be deliberately built, not assumed to transfer.

Maintaining consistent culture across global offices requires moving from aspirational values to operational infrastructure. The evidence from Kyndryl's Most Loved Workplace certification shows that when employees in Asia Pacific, Europe, North America, South America, and the UK independently describe their culture using the same language—'flexible work,' 'you are heard,' 'career and learning outcomes'—it is not coincidence. It is the result of systematic design: shared onboarding, visible leadership behavior, and consistent feedback loops that translate values into daily experience regardless of location or time zone.

A Most Loved Workplace® certification proves that a company's culture claims are independently verified through employee assessment—not self-reported surveys or marketing copy. The certification uses machine learning to analyze sentiment, emotion, and recurring themes across thousands of employee responses. When a large employer like Kyndryl earns this certification despite a major transformation, it demonstrates that their culture infrastructure survived and scaled through disruption, which is the hardest test any organizational culture can face.

About Louis Carter

Louis Carter is the Founder and CEO of Best Practice Institute (BPI) and Most Loved Workplaces®, a global research and certification organization helping companies build workplaces employees love. He is the creator of the Love of Workplace Index™, a research-based framework used to measure emotional connection between employees and their organizations and predict performance, retention, and culture outcomes. Carter is the author of more than a dozen books on leadership, talent development, and management best practices and has advised Fortune 500 companies, government agencies, and global organizations on leadership and culture transformation. He also hosted the Leader Show, a leadership interview series featured on Newsweek for five years, interviewing executives and leadership experts about leadership and the future of work. His work on workplace culture and leadership has been featured in major publications including Newsweek, The Wall Street Journal, and The Economist. Learn more in “How Louis Carter’s Most Loved Workplace Measures What Really Matters” (New York Business Now) and “Beyond Employer Branding: How Louis Carter Built the Global Standard for Workplace Culture” (NY Tech Media)

Get Certified?

Join 1,000+ Most Loved Workplaces®

In this Article

What's Next ?

Start your certification journey

Book a Call

Discuss your culture challenges with the Louis Carter team

Continue Reading